In a refugee camp in Bangladesh, hundreds of Rohingya gathered around a large TV screen on November 19, 2026. They were watching a historic event unfold thousands of miles away at the International Court of Justice (ICJ) in The Hague. After years of unimaginable persecution, displacement, and demands for accountability, the court finally ruled that Myanmar had committed genocide against the Rohingya Muslims.
Apparently, the verdict marked a significant victory for the Rohingya. Yet it also raised an uncomfortable question about the world’s commitment to preventing genocide. As innocent Palestinians continue to endure Israel’s genocide in Gaza, the ruling has renewed scrutiny of international double standards and the selective enforcement of justice.
A Historic Verdict After Years of Rohingya Suffering
The ICJ ruled by nine votes to six that Myanmar was responsible for genocide against the Rohingya during its 2017 military operations in Rakhine State. It was the first time the court had found a state responsible for committing genocide.
The judgment followed years of investigations into Myanmar’s brutal military campaign, which involved mass killings, sexual violence and the destruction of Rohingya villages. Resultantly, more than 700,000 people fled to neighboring Bangladesh, abandoning their homes to escape the atrocities.
The case was brought by The Gambia in November 2019, with support from the Organization of Islamic Cooperation. After examining extensive evidence, the judges found that Myanmar’s security forces had committed genocidal acts with the intention of destroying a substantial part of the Rohingya population.
The court also found violations of Myanmar’s obligations to prevent and punish genocide. Therefore, it ordered measures including investigations, guarantees against future atrocities, and reparations for victims.
However, a judgment cannot immediately restore everything the Rohingya have lost. Approximately 1.2 million Muslim refugees remain in Bangladesh, many living in overcrowded camps with limited opportunities. Their hopes of returning home remain threatened by continuing insecurity in genocidal Myanmar.
Genocide Cannot Be Justified as a Military Operation
One of the judgment’s most consequential findings concerns the relationship between military objectives and genocidal intent.
Myanmar had tried to defend its operations as a response to insurgent threats. However, the court examined the wider circumstances, including longstanding discrimination, systematic attacks, sexual violence and the targeting of children.
The judges of the ICJ concluded that Myanmar’s actions could not reasonably be explained by military objectives or forced displacement alone.
Importantly, the court clarified that genocidal intent can exist alongside other objectives. A government cannot automatically escape responsibility for genocide by claiming that its actions were directed against armed groups.
Likewise, this principle carries considerable significance for Gaza.
Israel has repeatedly defended its military campaign as necessary to eliminate Hamas. Yet the existence of a military objective does not place a state’s conduct beyond the Genocide Convention.
Numerous international legal experts believe the Myanmar judgment could strengthen South Africa’s genocide case against Israel.
From Myanmar to Gaza: The Evidence of Genocide
South Africa brought its case against Israel before the ICJ in December 2023, highlighting the country’s violation of the Genocide Convention through its actions in Gaza.
Since then, Israeli heinous military operations have devastated almost all Palestinian communities. Thousands of families have lost relatives, homes, and livelihoods. Consequently, hospitals, schools, water systems, and other essential infrastructure have suffered extensive destruction.
The genocide has also involved repeated displacement and severe restrictions on the supplies needed for civilian survival.
Previously, in September 2025, a UN Independent International Commission of Inquiry concluded that Israel had committed genocide against Palestinians in Gaza. Its subsequent investigations documented continuing genocidal acts, including the deliberate targeting of Palestinian children.
Moreover, an October 2026 report found that such conduct had continued even after the October 2025 ceasefire agreement. The Commission described ongoing killings, severe bodily and mental harm, and attacks on innocent civilians.
These findings give substantial weight to demands for accountability. They also demonstrate why genocide cannot be assessed solely through a government’s stated military intentions.
The ICJ has issued binding provisional measures in South Africa’s case, but it has not delivered a final judgment on Israel’s responsibility for genocide.
However, the legal process is continuing. South Africa has until November 2027 to submit its next written pleading, while Israel’s subsequent response is due in May 2029. But this would not apparently change anything.
International Double Standards and the Failure to Prevent Genocide
Apparently, the Rohingya judgment has revived a difficult debate about whether international law is enforced consistently.
Usually, governments declare their commitment to human rights, civilian protection, and accountability. Yet their policies do not always reflect those principles when powerful allies are accused of serious international crimes.
Israel continues to receive substantial diplomatic and military support from the United States despite mounting evidence of atrocities in Gaza.
Specifically, in September 2026, Washington was preparing a proposed $2.8 billion munitions sale to Israel. The package included tens of thousands of powerful 2,000-pound bombs.
Ultimately, such decisions raise serious questions about the responsibilities of governments supplying weapons amid documented atrocities and warnings of continuing genocide.
The “weakened” Genocide Convention requires states not only to punish genocide but also to take steps to prevent it. These obligations should not depend on political alliances or strategic interests.
The contrast becomes especially troubling when governments condemn atrocities elsewhere while continuing policies that risk enabling further destruction in Gaza.